Home passes PACER invoice as finances bureau states free entry to courtroom paperwork prices lower than $ 1 million a 12 months
We have come one step closer to free access to federal court documents. The House passed the 2020 Open Courts Act and passed it on to the Senate, which will decide whether the bill will land on the president’s desk.
Yes, something like this has happened before. And previous efforts always died on the way to the Oval Office. But this one could be different. A growing body of case law states that the US judicial system has overloaded users and illegally spent funds to improve the PACER system and, yes, reduce costs for users.
This latest effort has a little more momentum than its predecessor. And that seems to worry the US courts, which have backed up with dubious claims and even more dubious budget estimates. The court system claims it will cost at least $ 2 billion in the next few years to overtake PACER and allow free access to documents. Experts say it will cost far less.
A group of former government technologists and IT professionals deny that number. In a letter sent to the United States Justice Conference last week, the group estimated that the cost of a new system would be $ 10 million to $ 20 million in 36 months to build the system, and between $ 3 and $ 5 million annually for maintenance and development.
The Congressional Budget Office’s estimate is even worse. According to his report, repairing the system and giving most users open access would cost less than $ 1 million a year.
CBO estimates that the enactment of HR 8235 would increase the deficit by $ 9 million over the 2021-2030 period.
According to the report, the system overhaul will cost around $ 46 million. This is offset, however, by fees that the court system may impose on “large volume, for-profit users,” which the CBO estimates at around $ 47 million over the same period. After deducting some expected revenue declines and indirect tax effects, the court system is expected to generate net income of around $ 37 million over the next decade.
That should, but probably won’t, end the debate about cost. For some reason the judicial system continues to insist on giving citizens free access to court documents, which would bankrupt the system. If it finds allies in the Senate who are susceptible to its bad math, it could end the run of this bill.
But nobody but the court system agrees with the mathematics of the court system. It is not just potential beneficiaries of free access that provide much lower cost estimates. The government itself does not agree with the budgetary assumptions of this industry. Hopefully the CBO and the tireless work of transparency advocates will finally push PACER past the Senate and onto the president’s desk.
House passes PACER bill as budget bureau states free access to court documents costs less than $ 1 million a year
More Techdirt Legal Stories:
The Supreme Court says Muslim men can sue the FBI for being put on the no-fly list for refusing to become informants
Deep Dive reveals that the FCC’s Covid response was largely theatrical nonsense
ICE withdraws demand for sources for journalists after BuzzFeed supplanted its unconstitutional demand